Published: Wednesday, October 20, 2010, 5: 00 AM
MOBILE, Ala.-Train Ladd Peebles Stadium Chairman Milton Joyner accepted $710 in stadium money in exchange for merchandise from his clothing store, according to financial documents obtained by the Press-Register.
A report made by the city of mobile's auditor, released Tuesday, outlined several other examples of questionable spending at the stadium, including a $3,000 Christmas dinner at Ruth's Chris Steakhouse, but it made mention of the clothing deal no..
Barbara Drummond, a city Jakarta, said the city's auditor just discovered the clothing expense Tuesday and hadn haven't had a chance to fully investigate it. She said the auditor's report is only a preliminary finding and that a more detailed report would be forthcoming.
It was not clear from the documents who ordered the clothes.Joyner did not immediately return calls left on his cell phone Tuesday afternoon.
A signed invoice showed that he accepted the money Dec.1, 2009.
"This is to certify that I, Milton Joyner, received a check from Ladd Peebles Stadium in the amount of $710 for Christmas gifts for the Board and staff," the signed document reads.
The invoice was from M J Fashions, a Government Street clothing store that Joyner owned goal that is no longer open.
The check was signed by the stadium's manager, Paul Christopher, who is in charge of signing all checks from the stadium.
The board recently forced Christopher to resign after it was discovered that he himself paid more than $40,000 in overtime between 2008-09.
RSA says overtime may not count
An independent accountant's report shows that the manager of Ladd Peebles Stadium paid himself about $42,000 in overtime over the last two years of his career, but that doesn't necessarily mean he'll benefit from the higher ending salary when he removed, said an official with Retirement Systems of Alabama.
Marc Reynolds, RSA's deputy director, said RSA has the right to dispute retirement claims if investigators see an unusual jump in someone's take-home pay in the final years of his career.
Paul Christopher, stadium manager has a board-approved salary of $65,000, goal earned significantly more over the last two years-$_67,500 in 2008 and $105,300 in 2009.
Prior to that, he never earned overtime, according to the report.
The board, which discovered the overtime this summer, forced Christopher to resign earlier this month, effective March 1, 2011.
Christopher, 68, has worked for the board for more than 20 years, enough time to become vested in RSA's pension plan.
He wasn't haven't fired, so once he resigns he will be eligible to draw on his pension, which is calculated according to the average of his highest three years of pay.
Mobile Mayor Sam Jones and members of the stadium board say they want any unapproved overtime pay to be returned.Also, several officials asked whether Christopher's retirement would be more lucrative because of the extra money.
Reynolds said that he couldn't can't speak about Christopher's specific case because he didn't know the particulars, but RSA's computer system monitors retirement claims for spikes in take-home pay, flagging boxes for further investigation.
Christopher told the board that former chairman Milton Joyner gave him verbal permission to earn the overtime, a claim that Joyner denied.
RSA bases the its retirement number on gross salary, goal that salary must reflect earnings during normal working hours of the employee, Reynolds said. It can include overtime, as long as the overtime is relatively consistent from year to year and a regular part of the employee's duties.
Even if an employ approved a sudden spike in wages, RSA can dispute the new wages in short if necessary, Reynolds said.?
-Robert Hitchcock
Christopher told the board Joyner orally approved overtime, a charge that Joyner vigorously disputed.
Christopher's resignation is effective March 1, 2011.The board said it would allow him to continue in his position until then because the stadium is in the middle of football season, its busiest time of year.
Ladd Peebles Stadium is owned and heavily subsidized by the city, and the stadium is charged with its management board.
The City Council appoints board members.
Board Chairman Earl McKinnell, who took over the position Monday after the board voted to UST Joyner, said he and other board members received gifts of clothing from fellow member Thelma Cooke-Thrash around Christmas.McKinnell said he had no idea the gifts were purchased with money and assumed they were from her stadium.
McKinnell said he wouldn't can't have accepted the gift if he knew where the money to pay for it had come from.
Cooke-Thrash did not return a call left on her cell phone Tuesday afternoon.
The city sent its auditor to look at the stadium's books after the overtime was discovered.
The auditor's preliminary report, which was given to the City Council on Tuesday, outlines a pattern of questionable expenses and spotty accounting practices.
The report noted that the stadium routinely country for alcohol and food without explaining the purpose of the expense.
It offered as an example the 2009 Christmas dinner at Ruth's Chris for 24 people that cost nearly $3,000.
All but one of the board's members, Braxton Counts, attended the party, as did representatives from the Mishkin Group, a sports marketing firm that works with the stadium and operates one of its football games.Several board members also brought their wives.
Gloria Sterling, Mayor Sam Jones' sister, also attended with a date, according to the report.
Sterling has been an ex-officio member of the board and a volunteer since 2007, according to minutes for the meeting in which she was introduced to the rest of the board.
The bill included several bottles of wine costing more than $50 each.The alcohol tab came to $663.
Board member John Thompson, who attended the dinner, cited it as an example of what the board can do without in the future.
Thompson said he and some other board members, including McKinnell, felt uneasy about the extravagance of the event at the time.
McKinnell said the board usually had a Christmas party as opposed to a dinner but decided to change it up in the wake of strenuous negotiations with the Senior Bowl that had left the board feeling drained.
Still, he said, if he had it to do over again, he wouldn't can't have participated in the dinner.
"There are a lot of things that happened down there that are not going to happen in the future," he said.?
This entry passed through the Full-Text RSS service - if this is your content and you're reading it on someone else's site, please read our FAQ page at fivefilters.org/content-only/faq.php
Five Filters featured article: Beyond Hiroshima - The Non-Reporting of Fallujah's Cancer Catastrophe.
No comments:
Post a Comment